Autopsy Report

Observation #1

Nathan's sustained injuries to the back of his head and elbow before he died.

  • He must have fallen back onto the ice and landed on his head and elbow. The killer then sliced his throat from above.

Observation #2

The killer is right-handed.

Observation #3

The killer must have slashed twice with the unattached skateblade.

Contact Letter

Observation #1

Sofia's coach was killed with her own ice skate, making her the prime suspect.

  • Ruh-roh.

Observation #2

It would be a hoot if we once again were in direct contact with the killer like the old days.

Observation #3

Nice, she gives us our list of suspects right off the bat.

  • Carol Donnelly: administrator at the rink
  • Lillian Varma: Nathan's newest student
  • Harrison Campbell: Nathan's oldest student
  • Anne Campbell: Harrison's mother and manager
  • Kingston Lee: ice skating reporter
  • Marcus Lourdes: another coach at the rink
  • Sofia de la Torre: our contact

Crime Scene Report

Observation #1

Nathan's body was found by Kingston Lee, lying on his back in a pool of his own blood.

  • Near the southeast entrance of Ring A.

Observation #2

All entrances except the east were closed.

Observation #3

According to Kingston, the front entrance doors had been left unlocked, despite the building being closed to the public.

Observation #4

All of the suspects except Sofia, were also in the building upon police arrival.

Observation #5

There was a partial shoe print (approximately 8" in length) pointing toward the locker rooms (toward the southeast entrance) and the murder weapon was found just outside the southeast entrance door.

  • The murderer sliced Nathan's throat and then proceeded to the locker rooms, ditching the murder weapon once outside of the rink.

Observation #6

The killer tried to burn their shoes and gloves in the generator room furnace, but partial items remained.

Observation #7

The note that was found by Nathan's left ankle reads: "We've got to talk this out. Meet me after practice ASAP."

Observation #8

Nathan didn't have a password for his phone. It was open to the phone app with the numbers "719-2" already punched in.

Magazine Article

Observation #1

This piece gives us a little background on the victim and suspects.

Observation #2

Nathan and Carol were a long-time skating pair. The article states that Nathan had many jilted lovers.

  • Could Carol have eventually become one of those lovers?

Nathan's Medal

Observation #1

The medal is for 1st place Junior Pair.

  • This must be from Nathan's youth when he skated with Carol.

Notebook

Observation #1

This provides us with some basic rules and regulations,a glossary of figure skating terms, as well as some other possible useful information.

Observation #2

The phone number in the back cover is a live number.

  • Marcus Lourdes is the only one who doesn't say "Have an ice day."

Rink Brochure

Observation #1

There is a map inside.

  • The southeast entrance of the rink is right in front of the women's locker room.

Security Log

Observation #1 → Front Desk

Motion detected at:

  • 05:04:01
  • 05:12:20
  • 10:56:11

Observation #2 → Front Vestibule Inner Doors

Motion detected at:

  • 05:03:31
  • 05:47:06
  • 06:00:20
  • 06:14:52
  • 06:29:14
  • 06:48:13
  • 06:48:14
  • 07:19:51
  • 09:31:06
  • 09:56:15
  • 10:02:06
  • 10:08:30
  • 10:13:48
  • 10:29:01
  • 10:31:17

Observation #3 → Front Vestibule Outer Doors

Motion detected at:

  • 05:03:21
  • 05:46:58
  • 06:00:09
  • 06:14:41
  • 06:29:05
  • 06:47:56
  • 06:48:02
  • 07:19:42
  • 09:31:17
  • 09:56:05
  • 10:02:14
  • 10:08:39
  • 10:13:37
  • 10:28:54
  • 10:31:10

Observation #4 → Generator & Furnace

Motion detected at:

  • 10:15:46
  • 10:19:04
  • 10:19:43
  • 10:20:17

Observation #5 → Offices #102

Motion detected at:

  • 06:18:56
  • 09:13:27
  • 09:23:50
  • 09:29:01
  • 09:39:45
  • 09:42:03
  • 09:55:48
  • 10:07:53

Observation #6 → Offices #104

Motion detected at:

  • 06:07:19
  • 06:32:42
  • 09:26:09
  • 09:34:06
  • 09:37:52
  • 09:37:58
  • 10:08:47
  • 10:17:39

Observation #7 → Offices #105

Motion detected at:

  • 07:23:08
  • 07:34:51

Observation #8 → Offices CR1

Motion detected at:

  • 09:10:51
  • 09:10:53
  • 09:41:34
  • 09:47:13
  • 10:06:54
  • 10:07:09

Observation #9 → Offices CR2

Motion detected at:

  • 06:56:57
  • 08:01:16
  • 09:39:26
  • 09:40:58

Skate Bag

containing handwritten note

Observation #1

This bag is from "The Lee Report" and belongs to Kingston.

Observation #2

The paper inside contains his personal notes.

Suspect Interviews

Anne Campbell

Observation #1

Wow, all this lady cares about is her son's career.

Carol Donnelly

Observation #1

While she was out for breakfast, Nathan had submitted a request to avoid sharing the rink with Marcus during practice.

Kingston Lee

Observation #1

Nathan and Marcus got into a physical altercation.

Observation #2

Anne accused Nathan of ruining Harrison's career.

Observation #3

Nathan threatened to get Kingston banned from the rink.

Marcus Lourdes

Observation #1

According to Marcus, the scream heard a little after 10:00 AM was from a young woman.

Sofia de la Torre

Observation #1

Sofia reveals she is the one who everyone heard screaming.

Observation #2

She said she removed her skate blade to replace it.

  • Where did she leave it?
  • Could someone have picked it up to use for murder?

Observation #3

After the argument, she left the building and called Nathan from her car.

Password

AXEL

Observation #1

Nice! They improved it even more where we get notification dots for new items!

Observation #2

Michelle has once again given us a Spotify playlist.

Security Portal

Username

CDonne

Password

SkateforTomorrow3FTh

Guilty Until Proven Innocent

  • Anne Campbell
  • Carol Donnelly
  • Harrison Campbell
  • Kingston Lee
  • Lillian Varma
  • Marcus Lourdes
  • Sofia de la Torre

Events So Far

5:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly arrived at the rink.

5:45 AM - 5:50 AM

  • Kingston Lee arrived at the rink.

6:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly began work.

7:15 AM

  • Marcus Lourdes arrived at the rink.

7:30 AM

  • All rink attendees began arguing.

9:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly stepped out for breakfast in the staff lounge.
  • Marcus Lourdes left the rink to go to the gym.

10:00 AM

  • Kingston Lee left the rink before returning some time after.
  • Approximate time that Sofia de la Torre got into an argument with Nathan LaPalma.

10:13 AM

  • Sofia de la Torre left the building.

10:14 AM

  • Approximate time of death of Nathan LaPalma.

10:19 AM

  • Kingston Lee reported Nathan LaPalma's murder to the police.

Solution #1 → What is the file name that gives Sofia de la Torre an alibi?

10:13:40

Solution #2 → Who else is innocent?

Kingston Lee

Agenda Page

Observation #1

This is a page out of Anne's planner.

Observation #2

Hmm, seems Anne and Nathan were a thing...

Article Draft

Observation #1

This is an article that Anne has added notations to.

Card Holder

containing business card

Observation #1

The business card inside belongs to Anne.

Observation #2

OMG, she included "full-time mom" as a credential...

  • She is so full of her herself, it hurts.

Observation #3

Lining the edge design on the back with the design on the holder reveals the saying:

  • "SOAR WITH ATTITUDE"

Contact Letter

Observation #1

Once again, our contact is committing a crime in order to solve a murder...

  • She wants us to crack Harrison's passcode so she can snoop through his phone.

Lillian and Marcus's Emails

Observation #1

This transaction documents Lillian leaving Marcus as a coach for Nathan.

Observation #2

It also mentions the "cross-eyed" pigeon comment that according to the article draft was said by Harrison, not Marcus.

Phone Accessory

Observation #1

This is a popsocket with Harrison's lettered logo on it.

Observation #2

It says "TURN YOUR WORLD UPSIDE DOWN".

Routine Evaluations

Observation #1

These are just Nathan's mind maps and notes of routines.

Observation #2

Using Harrison's slogan "Turn Your World Upside Down" and his current routine (Jazz Suite No. 2), we can crack his passcode.

  • Turn the design upside and make believe you are looking at numbers on a keypad.

Written Requests

Anne Campbell

Observation #1

Anne requested that her son, Harrison, be allowed to have a lettered logo on the back of his costume.

Kurtis Linford

Observation #1

This guy is simply asking to have Nathan's office cleared out after his death. Carol still hasn't cleaned it out after weeks of non-use.

Nathan LaPalma

Observation #1

This is Nathan's request to no longer share the ice during practice times with Marcus.

Password

TOELOOP

Guilty Until Proven Innocent

  • Anne Campbell
  • Carol Donnelly
  • Harrison Campbell
  • K̶i̶n̶g̶s̶t̶o̶n̶ ̶L̶e̶e̶
  • Lillian Varma
  • Marcus Lourdes
  • S̶o̶f̶i̶a̶ ̶d̶e̶ ̶l̶a̶ ̶T̶o̶r̶r̶e̶

Events So Far

5:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly arrived at the rink.

5:45 AM - 5:50 AM

  • Kingston Lee arrived at the rink.

6:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly began work.

7:15 AM

  • Marcus Lourdes arrived at the rink.

7:30 AM

  • All rink attendees began arguing.

9:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly stepped out for breakfast in the staff lounge.
  • Marcus Lourdes left the rink to go to the gym.

10:00 AM

  • Kingston Lee left the rink before returning some time after.
  • Approximate time that Sofia de la Torre got into an argument with Nathan LaPalma.

10:12 AM

  • Anne Campbell was snooping in Nathan LaPalma's office for his agenda book.

10:13 AM

  • Sofia de la Torre left the building.

10:14 AM

  • Approximate time of death of Nathan LaPalma.

10:19 AM

  • Kingston Lee reported Nathan LaPalma's murder to the police.

Solution #1 → What is the passcode to Harrison's phone?

3259741

Solution #2 → What is Harrison's private Birdlr account username?

inredge_lord

Solution #3 → What is Harrison's private Birdr account password?

SoarwithAttitude11

Solution #4 → Who is innocent?

Anne Campbell

ASA Complaints

Observation #1

Nathan apparently brought his dog to the rink daily.

Observation #2

I wonder if the footage Nathan confiscated from Kingston is stored in his office.

Ashtray

Observation #1

This is a very nice ashtray. I'll definitely be using it.

Observation #2

It states: "Best Coach Five Years in a Row".

Bulletin Post

Observation #1

The keypads on the office doors require a 7-digit code.

Observation #2

Nathan's actually disregarded 5 (!!) rules of the rink.

Card from Nathan

Observation #1

This is a card from Nathan to Lillian telling her they can no longer practice a certain move.

Contact Letter

Observation #1

Our objective in this episode is to find the combination for the keypad of Nathan's office in order for Sofia to gain access.

Dog Tag

Observation #1

Nathan's dog's name is Lutz. It must have been a birthday present.

Marcus's Memo

Observation #1

Marcus lays down the law while revealing numerous rules that have been violated.

Note from Lillian

Observation #1

This is a note from Lillian to Marcus.

Observation #2

She apologizes for her emails to him from Episode 2 and says she preferred his coaching over Nathan's.

Observation #3

She couldn't handle Nathan telling her the truth about not being able to perform a certain way due to her illness and time constraints.

Rink Rules

Observation #1

Based on one of Harrison's private Birdl posts and his card to Lillian, Nathan broke rules 12 and 17.

Observation #2

Nathan drew what looks like a scribble in the upper-left corner of this poster, but it is actually an intricate design.

Password

SALCHOW

Guilty Until Proven Innocent

  • A̶n̶n̶e̶ ̶C̶a̶m̶p̶b̶e̶l̶l̶
  • Carol Donnelly
  • Harrison Campbell
  • K̶i̶n̶g̶s̶t̶o̶n̶ ̶L̶e̶e̶
  • Lillian Varma
  • Marcus Lourdes
  • S̶o̶f̶i̶a̶ ̶d̶e̶ ̶l̶a̶ ̶T̶o̶r̶r̶e̶

Events So Far

5:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly arrived at the rink.

5:45 AM - 5:50 AM

  • Kingston Lee arrived at the rink.

6:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly began work.

7:15 AM

  • Marcus Lourdes arrived at the rink.

7:30 AM

  • All rink attendees began arguing.

9:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly stepped out for breakfast in the staff lounge.
  • Marcus Lourdes left the rink to go to the gym.

10:00 AM

  • Kingston Lee left the rink before returning some time after.
  • Approximate time that Sofia de la Torre got into an argument with Nathan LaPalma.

10:12 AM

  • Anne Campbell was snooping in Nathan LaPalma's office for his agenda book.

10:13 AM

  • Sofia de la Torre left the building.

10:14 AM

  • Approximate time of death of Nathan LaPalma.

10:19 AM

  • Kingston Lee reported Nathan LaPalma's murder to the police.

Solution #1 → What is the keypad combination for Nathan's office?

1174612

Solution #2 → What is Nathan's computer password?

YSCOH

Coaster

Observation #1

Nathan "accidentally" stole this.

Contact Letter

Observation #1

Sophia needs us to find the address of Nathan's second house so that she can break in and do some more espionaging.

Direct Message Screenshot

Observation #1 

Nathan said he found a camera at the rink and suspected someone (Kingston) of spying on routines.

Observation #2

Nathan broke up with Anne via text.

Dogsitter Directions

Observation #1

Nathan mentions the "old place at #26".

  • Could this be his other house?

Observation #2

He started to give a hint as to the door code.

  • He applied the scores he and Anne had discussed previously to a default.

Keychain

Observation #1

Nathan found this at a tourist spot across town while walking his dog.

Marcus's Invitation

Observation #1

Why was Marcus wanting to "get to know" Carol more all of a sudden?

Newspaper Article

Observation #1

This is the article Kingston wrote splaying Nathan's dirty laundry and opening up an entirely new investigation.

Quick Start Guide

Observation #1

This was Nathan's guide for how to set up the alarm code of his second house.

Observation #2

The default code is 87654321.

Sticky Note

Observation #1

The H&L Program is what Nathan discussed with Anne in the direct messages.

Observation #2

If we can find the points earned for each of the bulleted routines, we can figure out what he had to reset his alarm code to for his second house.

Observation #3

Lillian's and Harrison's posts on the Three Pines Case website offer a little insight.

  • Ch Sq → +1
  • S Sp → -1
  • 3 Tw → 0
  • 2 S → +4
  • 2 S → +3
  • 2 Li → +3
  • P Sp → +5
  • 3 FTh → +5

Town Map

Observation #1

WTF kind of map is this?!

Password

EULER

Guilty Until Proven Innocent

  • A̶n̶n̶e̶ ̶C̶a̶m̶p̶b̶e̶l̶l̶
  • Carol Donnelly
  • Harrison Campbell
  • K̶i̶n̶g̶s̶t̶o̶n̶ ̶L̶e̶e̶
  • Lillian Varma
  • Marcus Lourdes
  • S̶o̶f̶i̶a̶ ̶d̶e̶ ̶l̶a̶ ̶T̶o̶r̶r̶e̶

Events So Far

5:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly arrived at the rink.

5:45 AM - 5:50 AM

  • Kingston Lee arrived at the rink.

6:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly began work.

7:15 AM

  • Marcus Lourdes arrived at the rink.

7:30 AM

  • All rink attendees began arguing.

9:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly stepped out for breakfast in the staff lounge.
  • Marcus Lourdes left the rink to go to the gym.

10:00 AM

  • Kingston Lee left the rink before returning some time after.
  • Approximate time that Sofia de la Torre got into an argument with Nathan LaPalma.

10:12 AM

  • Anne Campbell was snooping in Nathan LaPalma's office for his agenda book.

10:13 AM

  • Sofia de la Torre left the building.

10:14 AM

  • Approximate time of death of Nathan LaPalma.

10:19 AM

  • Kingston Lee reported Nathan LaPalma's murder to the police.

Solution #1 → What is the address of Nathan's second residence?

26 Bunyan Drive

Solution #2 → What is the security code of Nathan's second residence?

96697676

Contact Letter

Observation #1

Sofia figures if we can track down the time the video was taken and check out the light presets, that we will be able to deduce who else was involved in the conversation with Marcus.

Contract

Observation #1

Someone was looking to work with the company that made the mint tin.

Instruction Sheet

Observation #1

This is a legend for the light booth buttons and controls.

Journal Page

Observation #1

This is a page out of Lillian's journal.

Observation #2

She wrote a few lines in code.

Observation #3

Using Nathan's sticker instructions from the team morale assessment, we can decipher the messages.

Observation #4

The capital letters followed by numbers are "coordinates" to find on the sticker sheets.

Observation #5

Replace the capital letters with the first letter of the sticker meanings.

  • For example, B7 = orange heart = maneuvering outstanding. D4 = yellow rectangle = loop improvement needed.
  • Therefore, B7 = MO and D4 = LI
  • MO + ra + LI + ty = MORALITY

Observation #6

Once decoded, the messages read:

  • MORALITY
  • LIABILITY
  • INDEMNITY
  • NON COMPETE
  • CONFIDENTIALITY

Light Booth Presets

Observation #1

This is a list of presets for certain events.

Mint Tin

containing stickers

Observation #1

Caffeinated mints?! Never heard of such a thing.

Pin

Observation #1

This is a ferret.

Pitch Folder

containing pitch deck

Observation #1

On the back of the last page, there appears to be a conversation between Carol and Marcus.

Observation #2

In the back of the folder is further conversation with a code.

Observation #3

Marcus gives a hint for what the code is.

Observation #4

The pin depicts a ferret.

Observation #5

Each message is decoded by adding the number to the letters that follow it.

  • 2dc = d + 2 = F / c + 2 = e
  • 1qq = q + 1 = r / q + 1 = r
  • 3b = b + 3 = e
  • 4p = p + 4 = t

Observation #6

Once decoded, the messages read:

  • HARRISON'S CONTRACTOR
  • KILL HIS DEAL
  • CHANGED YOUR MIND
  • FERRET

Rink Room Reservation Schedule

Observation #1

There is more code at the bottom of the page. Use the same method used for the pitch folder.

Observation #2

The message at the bottom is a simple Caesar cipher. Shift the letters forward in the alphabet using the number that appears beforehand.

Observation #3

Once decoded, the message reads:

  • "I PULLED a few STRINGS for that CONTRACT, so don't tell ANNA until the DEAL IS COMPLETE. You'll be FREE soon enough."

Team Morale Assessment

Observation #1

Nathan gives instructions on how to use the stickers that are in the mint tin.

Password

FLIP

Guilty Until Proven Innocent

  • A̶n̶n̶e̶ ̶C̶a̶m̶p̶b̶e̶l̶l̶
  • Carol Donnelly
  • Harrison Campbell
  • K̶i̶n̶g̶s̶t̶o̶n̶ ̶L̶e̶e̶
  • Lillian Varma
  • Marcus Lourdes
  • S̶o̶f̶i̶a̶ ̶d̶e̶ ̶l̶a̶ ̶T̶o̶r̶r̶e̶

Events So Far

5:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly arrived at the rink.

5:45 AM - 5:50 AM

  • Kingston Lee arrived at the rink.

6:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly began work.

7:15 AM

  • Marcus Lourdes arrived at the rink.

7:30 AM

  • All rink attendees began arguing.

9:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly stepped out for breakfast in the staff lounge.
  • Marcus Lourdes left the rink to go to the gym.

10:00 AM

  • Kingston Lee left the rink before returning some time after.
  • Approximate time that Sofia de la Torre got into an argument with Nathan LaPalma.

10:12 AM

  • Anne Campbell was snooping in Nathan LaPalma's office for his agenda book.

10:13 AM

  • Sofia de la Torre left the building.

10:14 AM

  • Approximate time of death of Nathan LaPalma.

10:19 AM

  • Kingston Lee reported Nathan LaPalma's murder to the police.

Solution #1 → What time was the video taken?

5:30

Solution #2 → Who was in the light booth?

Lillian Varma

Carol's Emails

Observation #1

Carol reveals that she's been using a rental car for the past few weeks.

Observation #2

She also mentions winning a SAIST tournament back in her heyday.

Contact Letter

Observation #1

We have narrowed it down to three suspects:

  • Marcus Lourdes
  • Harrison Campbell
  • Carol Donnelly

Encoded Note

Observation #1

The last line mentions "adding a twist", meaning there is an extra step to decoding the words this time around.

Observation #2

This is another Caesar cipher like the one in Episode 5. Shift the letters forward in the alphabet using the number that precedes it.

Observation #3

The decoded words become:

  • AHNNTA
  • FTOCRNON
  • OYU
  • DBIRBE
  • NIUR
  • NILILASL
  • OERCS
  • TROPNOFTI
  • DOLOB
  • RBNU
  • ENO
  • GEOVL
  • AEFNUR
  • ARPI

Observation #4

Next, we must unscramble the decoded words.

Observation #5

The final words are:

  • NATHAN
  • CONFRONT
  • YOU
  • BRIBED
  • RUIN
  • LILLIAN'S
  • SCORE
  • FOOTPRINT
  • BLOOD
  • BURN
  • ONE
  • GLOVE
  • FURNACE
  • PAIR

Marcus's Memoir Outtakes

Observation #1

We get an idea of Marcus's relationships with Carol and Harrison, as well as his disdain for Nathan.

Paperweight

Observation #1

This was found on Carol's desk away from her other trophies.

Police Report

Observation #1

This is the police report Sofia filed after the attempted hit-and-run.

Observation #2

The vehicle she saw was a black convertible with a license plate containing the letters J and D.

Registered Vehicle List

Observation #1

There are two black convertibles on this list.

  • One belonging to Talia Astor - license plate 66F-DOJ.
  • The second belonging to Eliza Martin - license plate 47J-FFH.

Observation #2

Sofia saw the letters D and J on the car that attempted to run her over.

  • So we should focus on the car registered to Talia Astor, which is also the maiden name of Marcus's mother.

Sweatband

Observation #1

It says "ICELIFE".

Welcome Packet

Observation #1

So, every 5 years, SAIST feels the need to alter their logo...?

Password

FROZEN

Guilty Until Proven Innocent

  • A̶n̶n̶e̶ ̶C̶a̶m̶p̶b̶e̶l̶l̶
  • Carol Donnelly
  • Harrison Campbell
  • K̶i̶n̶g̶s̶t̶o̶n̶ ̶L̶e̶e̶
  • L̶i̶l̶l̶i̶a̶n̶ ̶V̶a̶r̶m̶a̶
  • Marcus Lourdes
  • S̶o̶f̶i̶a̶ ̶d̶e̶ ̶l̶a̶ ̶T̶o̶r̶r̶e̶

Events So Far

5:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly arrived at the rink.

5:45 AM - 5:50 AM

  • Kingston Lee arrived at the rink.

6:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly began work.

7:15 AM

  • Marcus Lourdes arrived at the rink.

7:30 AM

  • All rink attendees began arguing.

9:00 AM

  • Carol Donnelly stepped out for breakfast in the staff lounge.
  • Marcus Lourdes left the rink to go to the gym.

10:00 AM

  • Kingston Lee left the rink before returning some time after.
  • Approximate time that Sofia de la Torre got into an argument with Nathan LaPalma.

10:12 AM

  • Anne Campbell was snooping in Nathan LaPalma's office for his agenda book.

10:13 AM

  • Sofia de la Torre left the building.

10:14 AM

  • Approximate time of death of Nathan LaPalma.

10:19 AM

  • Kingston Lee reported Nathan LaPalma's murder to the police.

Solution #1 → Who tried to run over Sofia de la Torre?

Marcus Lourdes

Solution #2 → What is the combination to Marcus Lourdes' safe?

026862062

Solution #3 → Whose glove was Marcus Lourdes keeping in his safe?

Carol Donnelly