My Observations

Mallory Rock

Episode 5

Physical Items

  • Bar Napkin
  • Bridge Incident Article
  • Bridge Review
  • Business Registration
  • Flashlight
  • Gwen's Letter
  • Hendricks Group Files
  • Message Bottle
  • Star Map
  • Trauma Worksheets


  • Michelle Gray Investigations




  • Who is innocent?

Physical Items

Bar Napkin

Observation #1

This item was handed to Gwen by Jordan at The Rock Lounge.

  • He could not be bothered to get off the phone long enough to talk to her in person.

Observation #2

According to the napkin, The Rock Lounge is open until 2 am.

  • Jordan claims to have been there until close and then went straight home to bed.

Bridge Incident Article


The victims' families of the bridge collapse still have not seen a dime, whereas Jordan received money through his insurance.

Bridge Review


Martin's signature at the bottom of page 2 matches that of the first page of the group files.

Business Registration

Observation #1

This is the registration for the Anchor Management Company.

  • They specialize in land surveillance.

Observation #2

The address registered is 649 Summer Street.

  • This is one of JW Enterprises' current properties...
  • Does this mean Jordan is Anchor Management and is using one of his open property addresses to register the "business"?


Observation #1

Mine is red in color and was dead upon arrival.

Observation #2

It is also a bottle opener with a carabiner clip attached.

Gwen's Letter

Observation #1

Gwen found the original phone number from the threatening voicemail that was left for her in Episode 4.

  • 207-370-2420

Observation #2

Calling this number leads to the Anchor Management automated message.

Hendricks Group Files

Observation #1

Martin's signature is significantly different on the two forms.

Observation #2

The second signature matches the signature on the members list we received in Episode 4.

  • Who forged the other one, and why?

Message Bottle

Observation #1

Someone left this for Gwen under her windshield wiper.

Observation #2

It contains another threatening message.

  • Or perhaps a warning from someone who knows who the killer is?

Star Map

Observation #1

The "stars" of Ursa Major are punched out, as well as 3 more punches surrounding the constellation.

Observation #2

Notice the illustration at the bottom has the tip of a lighthouse on it?

  • This can be lined up with the illustration at the bottom of the vote record from Episode 4.

Observation #3

Standing the star map upright (perpendicular to the paper) and shining a light through the holes will project the Ursa Major constellation onto the paper.

Observation #4

To align the stars correctly, match the 3 triangle-forming stars to the 3 similar stars on the vote record.

  • The light projected onto the bolded stars means that member voted "YES".

Trauma Worksheets


These worksheets belong to Joey.

  • Poor guy was disrespected in every aspect of his life.


Michelle Gray Investigations

Observation #1


  • Your personal email

Observation #2



Observation #3 - Mallory



Observation #4 - Mallory → Screenshots → Friend Text

The time in the photo is 9:53 PM.

  • There is a sign saying "The Boss is OUT", meaning Jordan was not at the bar at this time.


4:43 PM

  • Samantha Gundy closed her shop.

4:45 PM

  • Elizabeth Ferris-Hendricks arrived at the Mariner's Lodge Hotel to meet with Gwen Ferris.

6:00 PM

  • Elizabeth Ferris-Hendricks met with her daughter Ruby Hendricks for dinner.
  • Josiah Hendricks claims he had dinner with Elizabeth Ferris-Hendricks and Ruby Hendricks, yet Ruby didn't mention him in her statement, only her mother.

7:00 PM

  • Ruby Hendricks ran home to find an empty house.

8:00 PM

  • Elizabeth Ferris-Hendricks had planned to "sort things out with Clarence" [Reaver].

8:43 PM

  • Approximate time Jordan Woodard left the party.

9:00 PM - 9:50 PM

  • Samantha Gundy was in the Navigators Clubhouse.

9:00 PM - 9:53 PM

  • Josiah Hendricks was at The Rock Lounge bar.

9:00 PM - 10:00 PM

  • Reverend Clarence Reaver was in attendance of the weekly Rocksteady Support group meeting.

9:10 PM

  • Time of Elizabeth Ferris-Hendricks' last comment on Good Fences.

9:30 PM

  • Martin Hendricks abruptly left his residence because he was late for a meeting with his son, Josiah Hendricks.

9:32 PM

  • Gwen Ferris called Martin Hendricks to check on the hotel pool's pump room. He was stuck there fixing it and missed his hang session with his son.

10:00 PM

  • Martin Hendricks was supposed to meet with his son, Josiah Hendricks, on their family boat. Martin had to cancel and Josiah claims he remained on the boat until morning.

10:13 PM

  • Latest time Beth Ferris-Hendrick's body could have entered the water.

10:43 PM

  • Elizabeth Ferris-Hendricks' watch stopped.

11:00 PM

  • Martin Hendricks finished fixing the hotel pool's pump and headed home.


Guilty Until Proven Innocent

  • Jody Hendricks
  • Jordan Woodard
  • Josiah Hendricks
  • Martin Hendricks
  • Clarence Reaver
  • Samantha Gundy


Subject Line


Who is innocent?

Josiah Hendricks