• Password
    • MRDR5241


⍻ 911 Transcript

⍻ Autopsy Report

⍻ Class Ring

⍻ Email Chain

⍻ High School Reunion Program

⍻ Legal Complaint

⍻ Letter from Private Investigator

⍻ Love Note

⍻ Newspaper Article

⍻ Prescription

⍻ Suspect Photos

⍻ Tin Box

⍻ Witness Statements

Physical Items

911 Transcript

  • This is a transcript of Aura McBride's 911 call after she found her cousin's body. It can be read while listening to the actual call provided on Michelle's website.

Autopsy Report

  • Why was he wearing different colored socks?
  • The perpetrator must have worn gloves, so how were there fingernail imprints?
  • They must have been strong or in a real rage to cause that much damage...
  • With the cranial and abdominal trauma, it's possible the passenger caused a car accident and then finished Charlie off with strangulation.

Class Ring

  • This is a gold-plated class ring from Chestnut Falls High School found at the crime scene.
    • We cannot discern if it belonged to a man or woman, as it is a size 8-1/2 and both men and women can have fingers this size.

Email Chain

  • This is an email exchange between Charlie and Susan.
  • Wow, such harsh language in the subject line...
  • Charlie was supplying meds to Susan's veterinary clinic. It seems he misjudged the amount of anesthesia he shipped to her.
    • It must have happened again since Susan is dealing with a lawsuit and she had threatened legal action.

High School Reunion Program

  • This is a program for the Chestnut Falls High School reunion.
  • We get a little background on some of the school alumni.

Legal Complaint

  • This is a copy of the legal complaint Susan Li filed against Charlie's pharmacy.
  • His repeated mistakes finally led to the death of one of Susan's patients.

Letter from Private Investigator

  • Michelle gives us access to the Deviant Tracker on her website.
  • She claims she has ruled out a suspect but that we may disagree with her.

Love Note

  • So, Charlie and Robyn dated in high school.
  • It appears as if they had to break up because of him getting accepted into college and her taking over her family's farm.
  • She was soooo "in love" with him.
    • Did he feel the same?
    • Did he break her heart?

Newspaper Article

  • This article is about Susan Li's patient who died because of Charlie's gross misdosage and mislabeling of medication.


  • This was found in the tin box.

Suspect Photos

  • These show us how our suspects look all grown up.

Tin Box

  • This is a cool little tin box. It was discovered at the crime scene.
  • Inside is a prescription written to Arthur Hughes for anti-anxiety meds.

Witness Statements

Sarah MacDonagh

  • The reason Sarah didn't go to the reunion with Charlie is that their daughter was sick.
  • I'm not buying it. Sounds like big, fat crocodile tears.

Robyn Dupre

  • She didn't see Charlie at all during the reunion.
  • After the reunion, she went home for a bit.
  • She got to Dimitri's at about 10:10 PM. She says Gavin came in after her, and Neeta after him. Nic was pretty late, which she found weird.

Nicholas Matsoukas

  • What did Nic want to talk to Charlie about...?
  • Drug business?
  • Nic reveals the reason he didn't show up right away was that he went to the bar to avoid his mother.

Neeta Patel

  • What a nosy little thing...
  • She claims she left her wallet at the hotel so she went there before the diner. She doesn't know what time she showed up but it was before Nic got there.
  • She was not a very cooperative witness...


MacDonagh Case

School Records

  • Password

    • CNH192
  • 1998

    • School Records
      • This is a blank document. Hmm.
    • Reunion
      • Gives us a screenshot of a post from Aura McBride.
      • This shows the high school gymnasium.
      • The basketball net is torn off and slung to the side of the backboard.
      • The clock on the wall reads 9:42 (assuming it's PM).


  • Username

    • grayinvestigations
  • Password

    • foghorn1212
  • Audio
    • Dahlia
      • Password
        • JMR508
  • Images
    • Kingfisher
      • Password
        • AHG775
      • Oh, come on! Who the heck really texts in code like this...?
      • You can copy and paste the coded messages and plug them into the automatic shift tool to decipher them.
      • The second text screenshot is an extension of the first.
      • Once decoded, the messages read...
        • Sarah: I can't do this anymore. He refuses to believe anything is wrong...
        • N: I know.
        • N: It won't be much longer. He'll have to realize then.
        • Sarah: Promise?
        • N: Are you in bed?
        • Sarah: No, I'm in the kitchen.
        • N: Go out on the porch and call me. He won't hear.
        • Sarah: ...Alright.
        • Sarah: Give me a minute.
      • Who is N? Could it be Neeta? Could it be Nic? He was seriously late showing up to the diner...
      • Were N and Sarah having an affair?
        • "Are you in bed?" is coded, why else would it be?
      • It doesn't look good for Sarah. It seems like she may have been plotting her husband's murder...
      • The signature on the receipt looks like it may be Sarah MacDonagh.
        • She ordered dinner for herself and Maggie.
        • Was this to try and establish some kind of alibi or a celebratory dinner?


  • Antonio Villar
  • Arthur Hughes
  • A̶u̶r̶a̶ ̶M̶c̶B̶r̶i̶d̶e̶
  • Gavin Nash
  • Neeta Patel
  • Nicholas Matsoukas
  • Robyn Dupre
  • Sarah MacDonagh
  • Susan Li


6:00 PM

  • High school reunion started.

8:40 PM

  • High school reunion ended.

9:00 PM

  • High school reunion ended.
  • Antonio Villar left the reunion and sat in the parking lot for a bit. He may or may not have seen Charles MacDonagh drive off with someone.

9:10 PM

  • Susan Li called her lawyer. They spoke for a half-hour or so.

9:12 PM

  • Order was placed by Sarah MacDonagh for delivery at Pizza & Subs located on Willow Ln.

9:35 PM - 9:40 PM

  • Estimated time of death of Charles MacDonagh verified by Dr. Kara Duncan.
  • *In real life, TOD can only be narrowed down to a range of hours, not exact minutes.

9:42 PM

  • Time on wall clock in Aura McBride's pic of "cleaning up after the reunion" posted on social media.

9:45 PM

  • Aura McBride claimed to have finished cleaning up after the reunion a little after this time.
  • Susan Li called Aura McBride. Aura did not answer.

10:00 PM

  • Arthur Hughes arrived at the bar shortly after this time. Antonio Villar was the only other alumni there.

10:10 PM

  • Robyn Dupre arrived at Dimitri's, followed by Gavin Nash and Neeta Patel.

10:15 PM

  • Aura McBride came upon the scene of the crime and discovered Charles MacDonagh's body.


Who is innocent?

  • Sarah MacDonagh