Casting Call Poster

  • Ray wrote on the back of this poster, at the behest of Emma.
  • Once deciphered, the messages read:
    • "NOT YET"
    • "FOR YOU"
    • "OR IS IT ALREADY WITH US?"
    • "HYDE"
    • "GOING TO HAVE TO DO SOMETHING DRASTIC"
    • "HE'S TURNING HER AGAINST ME. I HAVE TO GET HER SACK"
    • "DIE"
    • "KILL OR BE KILLED"

Finger Bone

  • This is a pretty long finger bone...
    • It must have belonged to a witch; according to the witch manuscript, limbs would elongate...
  • There are holes drilled through one end, as if it were meant to wear as a necklace charm.
  • The letter "E" is etched into it.
    • "E" for "Emma"?

Flare Gun Package

  • And... there's Morse code on the back.
  • Emma wrote on this document.
  • Once decoded, the messages read:
    • "I NEED TO DEFEND MYSELF."
    • "NO ONE WOULD BLAME ME"
    • "CALLING TO ME."
    • "RAY DEAD"
    • "SOMEONE SCREAMING"
    • "CAN'T TRUST MYSELF ANYMORE"

Have You Seen This Man Poster

  • This is a drawing of Carver from Season 1.
  • On the back are numerous messages in a whole new alphabet.
    • This can be easily figured out by looking for repeated letters, the most logical word made up with those letters, and then just plugging in the blank spaces.
  • Once deciphered, the messages read:
    • "IS IT YOU I'VE HEARD WHISPERING TO ME?"
    • "WHISPERING IN MY EAR"
    • "LOOKING UP AT ME?"
    • "INSIDE MY HEAD"
    • "WRONG"
    • "ME"
    • "I AM HE"

James's Notebook Pages

  • James is losing his shit...
  • Once deciphered, the messages read:
    • "ED ED ED"
    • "ROB"
    • "WATCH"
    • "ROB"
    • "WAIT"
    • "GET HIM BEFORE HE GETS YOU"
    • "NOW"
    • "HE WASN'T WRITING"
    • "HE WAS READING"
    • "THE WORDS ARE MINE"
  • Um, holy fuck, did James kill Robert?!

Letter from Ed

  • Ed found his cohorts' camp amassed with blood and aged, same as the van had been.
  • He also found a hunk of flesh at the campsite and needs our help deciphering the symbols carved into it.

Letter to Wife

  • Harriett's husband willingly entered the woods, sacrificing himself, before he couldn't resist anymore and ended up hurting her.
  • This is the same handwriting as the "wanted" poster, meaning Robert is the one who wrote on the back of that paper.
  • Once deciphered, the messages read:
    • "SOMEONE"
    • "KID, A YOUNG MAN, REALLY"
    • "HIS FACE"
    • "HIS VOICE"
    • "ALONE"
    • "TOGETHER"
    • "WITH BOTH OF US. WE'RE CHANGING."
    • "CONTORTING US ALL, BUT IT'S AFFECTING HIM FASTER."

Witch-Hunting Manuscript

  • This was written in the time when people believed in witches and would accuse pretty much anyone of witchcraft, whether there be proof or not.